CVS has two loyalty programs — the free ExtraCare card and the paid CarePass membership. Here’s the honest comparison so you can decide which is worth it for you.
- ExtraCare: Free — basic points and discounts for all CVS shoppers
- CarePass: $5/month — premium membership with 20% off and monthly rewards
- Best for light shoppers: ExtraCare (free is always better)
- Best for regular CVS shoppers: CarePass pays for itself if you spend $25+/month
5 Minutes
Sep 2026
Reynolds
CVS ExtraCare — The Free Program
ExtraCare is CVS’s complimentary loyalty program, open to all shoppers with no monthly fees or subscription required.
ExtraCare benefits include:
- Earn 2% back on most CVS purchases, paid as ExtraBucks rewards each quarter.
- Receive $3 in ExtraBucks rewards on your birthday.
- Access personalised ExtraCare deals and weekly coupons.
- Digital coupons are automatically added to your card via the CVS app.
- Track your rewards on cvs.com or through the CVS app.
ExtraCare does not include:
- Discounts on prescriptions beyond your insurance coverage
- Monthly reward credits
- 20% storewide discount
Cost: Free, with no monthly or annual fees.
Best for: Occasional CVS shoppers who want rewards without a paid membership commitment.
Full guide: /cvs-extracare-rewards-guide/
CVS CarePass: Paid Membership Program
CarePass is CVS’s premium paid membership, available for $5 per month or $48 per year, providing $12 in annual savings over monthly payments.
CarePass benefits include:
- Save 20% every day on CVS Health brand products.
- Save 20% on most CVS store brand products.
- $10 monthly reward credited to your account for use at CVS stores.
- Free 1-day delivery on CVS.com orders over $10.
- Access a 24/7 pharmacist helpline for immediate assistance.
- Access exclusive member deals and discounts.
CarePass exclusions include:
- Prescriptions (except CVS Health brand pharmacy items).
- Alcohol and tobacco products.
- Lottery, gift cards, and select other excluded categories.
Cost: $5 per month or $48 per year.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | ExtraCare (Free) | CarePass ($5/month) |
|---|---|---|
| Cost | Free | $5/month or $48/year |
| 2% back on purchases | Yes | Yes (stacked on top) |
| 20% off CVS Health brand | No | Yes — every day |
| Monthly $10 reward | No | Yes |
| Free delivery on CVS.com | No | Yes (orders over $10) |
| 24/7 pharmacist helpline | No | Yes |
| Birthday ExtraBucks | $3 | $3 |
| Weekly circular deals | Yes | Yes |
| Personalised coupons | Yes | Yes |
Is CarePass Cost-Effective?
The $10 monthly reward covers the $5 CarePass fee, providing a $5 net benefit before any 20% discounts are applied.
Calculation for a typical CVS shopper:
If you spend $50 per month on CVS Health brand products:
- A 20% discount saves you $10.
- With the $10 monthly reward, your total value is $20.
- After the $5 CarePass fee, your net savings are $15.
If you spend $25 per month:
- A 20% discount saves you $5.
- Including the $10 monthly reward, your total value is $15.
- After the $5 CarePass fee, your net savings are $10.
CarePass is cost-effective once you use the $10 monthly reward, making it financially beneficial for most CVS shoppers who redeem it.
Please note: You must use the $10 monthly reward before it expires. Unused rewards do not carry over.
Who Should Choose ExtraCare Only?
- You shop at CVS less than once per month.
- You primarily purchase name-brand products rather than CVS Health brand items.
- You prefer to avoid a recurring monthly charge.
- You already obtain most of your healthcare products through insurance.
Who Should Choose CarePass?
- You visit CVS at least once per month.
- You regularly purchase CVS Health brand or store brand products.
- You use CVS.com for online orders.
- You want access to a pharmacist helpline, which is especially helpful for caregivers or those who take regular medications and need pharmacy support.
Reynolds’ perspective: For most regular CVS shoppers, CarePass is worthwhile for the $10 monthly reward alone. The 20% discount on CVS brand products is an added benefit. CarePass is not recommended for infrequent shoppers who are unlikely to use the monthly reward.
Can You Have Both ExtraCare and CarePass?
Yes. CarePass is added to your existing ExtraCare account. When you enrol in CarePass, it links to your ExtraCare card, so you keep all ExtraCare benefits and gain additional CarePass features.
Frequently Asked Questions
For most regular CVS shoppers, the $10 monthly reward offsets the $5 fee, so the 20% discount effectively costs nothing extra.
Yes, you can cancel CarePass at any time through your CVS account or by calling CVS customer service. Annual plan cancellations may be subject to specific terms.
No, CarePass doesn’t offer discounts on most prescriptions. It applies only to CVS Health brand products and most store-brand items. You can get prescription discounts through insurance or separate programs such as GoodRx.
Yes, ExtraCare has been CVS’s free loyalty program for decades. CVS has not indicated it plans to charge for it.
Change Log
| Date | Update |
|---|---|
| Sep 2026 | CarePass pricing has been confirmed at $5 per month or $48 per year. |
| Sep 2026 | Confirmed the $10 monthly reward is still active |
| Sep 2026 | Added CarePass break-even calculation |
Reviewed by Reynolds
Last updated: Sep 2026
Contact Reynolds →
Related Guides:
- Walgreens Coupons 2026 — All Working Codes, myWalgreens and App Deals
- Walgreens Photo 2026 — Prints, Passport Photos and Same-Day Pickup
- CVS Photo 2026 — Prints, Passport Photos, Posters and Same-Day Pickup
- Walgreens Hours 2026 | Store & Pharmacy Opening and Closing Times
- CVS MinuteClinic 2026 — Walk-In Services, Costs and Locations
- CVS Hours 2026 — Store & Pharmacy Opening and Closing Times
- CVS Near Me 2026 — Find Your Nearest CVS Pharmacy + Hours
- CVS Weekly Ad Guide
- CVS CarePass vs ExtraCare — Which Is Better?
- How To Transfer A Prescription to Walgreens
- Walgreens Pharmacy Hours 2026
- How to Save Money at CVS 2026 – 15 Proven Tips & Hacks
- How to Use GoodRx at CVS and Walgreens
- CVS Pharmacy Hours 2026
- Walgreens myWalgreens Rewards — Complete Guide